Payroll, HR & workers’ comp consulting — call 866-684-5684.
All guides
Workers' Comp 4 min read

Pay-As-You-Go vs. Traditional Workers' Comp: Avoiding Big Upfront Deposits & Audit Surprises

Traditional workers' comp is priced on an estimate of next year's payroll, then corrected at audit. For seasonal businesses and growing contractors, that can mean a large deposit up front and a large bill afterward. Pay-as-you-go works differently.

How a traditional policy is billed

You estimate annual payroll by class code. The carrier calculates an estimated premium and usually collects a deposit, then installments.

After the policy year ends, a premium audit compares actual payroll to the estimate. If you grew or used more labor than expected, you owe the difference.

How pay-as-you-go is billed

Premium is calculated from the payroll you actually run each pay period and collected alongside payroll. A slow month costs less; a busy month costs more.

  • Smaller upfront payment in many programs
  • Premium tracks real payroll, so audits tend to show smaller adjustments
  • Requires accurate class code reporting each pay period

Who benefits most

Pay-as-you-go tends to fit businesses whose payroll moves around:

  • Seasonal operations such as landscaping, pools or holiday retail
  • Contractors that ramp crews up and down by project
  • New businesses without a reliable payroll history

Things to check before switching

An audit still happens at year end. Ask how your payroll provider reports class codes, whether there are program or service fees, and how the change affects your current policy's cancellation terms.

Quick answers

Is pay-as-you-go more expensive?
The rate is set by the carrier and your class codes, not the billing method. The main difference is when you pay, not necessarily how much.
Do I need a specific payroll provider?
Usually the program connects to your payroll so premium can be calculated each pay period. Compatibility varies by program.

General information only, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Rules vary by state; confirm with your state agency or a licensed professional.

Call 866-684-5684